Catholic Family News

Traditional Catholics Resist Traditionis Custodes in New Open Letter

Editor’s Note: Catholic Family News is pleased to help circulate the following open letter, which we reprint with permission from The Remnant (here).


Letter from the Faithful Attached to the Traditional Latin Mass, to Catholics of the Whole World

“What man is there among you, of whom if his son shall ask bread, will he reach him a stone?” (Mt 7:9)

Dear Brothers and Sisters in Christ,

We have been deeply saddened to learn of Pope Francis’ decision to revoke the main provisions of the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum promulgated by Pope Benedict XVI on July 7, 2007. After decades of division and quarrels, Summorum Pontificum was a source of peace and reconciliation for all Catholics.

Rome has violated Pope Benedict XVI’s solemn word in a brutal and rigid manner that is a far cry from the fraternal welcome that is nowadays so widely proclaimed.

Pope Francis’ explicit intent, as expressed in the Motu Proprio Traditionis Custodes of July 16, 2021, is to see an end of the celebration of the Holy Mass handed down by the Tradition of the Church. We are deeply shocked by this decision. How can we comprehend this radical break with the traditional Missal, which is the “venerable and ancient” enactment of the “law of the faith”, and has borne fruit in so many peoples, saints and missionaries? And what harm is being done by those faithful who simply want to pray as their fathers have prayed for so many centuries? Who can ignore the fact that the Tridentine Mass converts many souls, attracts young and fervent congregations, and inspires many vocations; that it has been the wellspring of seminaries, religious communities, and monasteries; that it is the mainstay of many schools, youth ministries, catechetical work, spiritual retreats and pilgrimages?

Many of you — our Catholic brothers, priests and bishops — have expressed to us your incomprehension and deep sorrow: we thank you for your numerous testimonies of support.

Summorum Pontificum’s stated purpose was to promote peace within the Church in order to build unity in charity, but it was also designed to lead Catholics to renew their ties with their own inheritance, by helping as many people as possible to discover the rich liturgical tradition that is the treasure of the Church. Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI is witnessing the destruction of his work of reconciliation in his own lifetime.

In this age of materialism and of harrowing social and cultural division, liturgical peace is an absolute necessity for the faith and spiritual life of Catholics, in a world that is dying of thirst. The drastic curtailment of the authorization to celebrate Mass in its traditional form will rekindle mistrust and doubt, and heralds the resurgence of a devastating liturgical quarrel that will rip apart the Christian people.

Before God and before all men, we solemnly affirm that we will not allow anyone to deprive the faithful of this treasure which is first and foremost that of the Church. We will not remain inactive in the face of the spiritual suffocation of vocations that the Motu Proprio Traditionis Custodes will bring about. We will not deprive our children of the unique means of transmitting the faith that is faithfulness to the traditional liturgy.

As loyal sons of their father, we ask of Pope Francis that he reverse his decision, repealing Traditionis Custodes and restoring full freedom to celebrate the Tridentine Mass, for the glory of God and the good of the faithful. Bread rather than stones.

September 8, 2021
Feast of the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary

Signatories Below:

Jeanne Smits, Journalist — Director of the Jeanne Smits Blog
Jean-Pierre Maugendre, Renaissance Catholique 
Philippe Maxence, Rédacteur en Chef de L’Homme Nouveau journaliste et écrivain 
Jean de Tauriers, Président de ND de Chrétienté 
Guillaume de Thieulloy, Editeur de presse Editeur de presse 
Charles de Meyer, Président de SOS Chrétiens d’Orient 
Benjamin Blanchard, DG de SOS Chrétiens d’Orient 
Christian Marquant, Président de Paix Liturgique 
Michel De Jaeghere, Journaliste et essayiste 
Hervé Rolland, Vice-Président de ND de Chrétienté 
Maike Hickson, LifeSiteNews Ecrivain 
Robert Hickson, Ecrivain 
Roberto de Mattei, Professeur 
Michael Matt, The Remnant Editor in chief 
Professeur Marie-Pauline Deswarte
Jean-Baptiste Pierchon, Docteur en Droit Mtre de conférences 
Hugues Petit, Docteur en Droit Professeur 
Jean Sévillia, Journaliste, Historien, Ecrivain 
Xavier Arnaud, Forum catholique Directeur 
Laurent Dandrieu, Journaliste 
Henri Sire, Ecrivain 
Jacques Charles-Gaffiot, Historien d’art 
Victor Aubert, Academia Christiana Président 
Bernard Antony, AGRIF Président 
Reynald Seycher, Professeur d’université 
François Billot de Lochner, Fondation de Service politique Président 
Anne Brassié, journaliste et écrivain 
Jérôme Triomphe, Avocat 
Cyrille Dounot, Professeur avocat eccl. 
Thibaud Collin, Philosophe et professeur 
Alvino-Mario Fantini, The European Conservative Editor in chief 
Paweł Milcarek, Christianitas Dir. Rédaction 
Marek Jurek, Ancien pdt de la Diète de Pologne 
Philippe Pichot-Bravard, Maître de conférence 
Philippe Lauvaux, ULB Paris Assas Professeur 
Claude Goyard, Paris Assas Professeur 
Philippe de Villiers, Ancien ministre, écrivain 
Max Guazzini
Pierre de Lauzun, Haut fonctionnaire Ecrivain 
Yves Daoudal, Journaliste — Directeur de Blog
Jean-Marie Molitor, Journaliste 
Michael Hageböck, Summorum Pontificum Freiburg Président

Avatar photo

Catholic Family News